| Year | Cross Country | Indoor Track & Field | Outdoor Track & Field | 
| 2023-24 | Release | Release | Release | 
| 2022-23 | Release | Release | Release | 
| 2021-22 | Release | Release | Release | 
| 2020-21 | Release | Release | Release | 
| 2019-20 | Release | Release | No Awards Given | 
| 2018-19 | Release | Release | Release | 
| 2017-18 | Release | Release | Release | 
| 2016-17 | Release | Release | Release | 
| 2015-16 | Release | Release | Release | 
| 2014-15 | Release | Release | Release | 
| 2013-14 | Release | Release | Release | 
| 2012-13 | |||
| 2011-12 | |||
| 2010-11 | |||
| 2009-10 | |||
| 2008-09 | |||
| 2007-08 | |||
| 2006-07 | |||
| 2005-06 | |||
| 2004-05 | Coming Soon | ||
| 2003-04 | Coming Soon | ||
| 2002-03 | Coming Soon | ||
| 2001-02 | Coming Soon | ||
| 2000-01 | Coming Soon | ||
| 1999-2000 | Coming Soon | Coming Soon | |
| – More Years Coming Soon – | |||
Historical Requirements for All-America
| Cross Country | |
| Year(s) | Requirements | 
| 1938-67 | Top 15 | 
| 1968-71 | Top 25 | 
| 1972-73 | Top 25, to include the top 25 University Division/Division I | 
| 1974 | Foreign-born athletes in the top 25 finishers and top 25 U.S.-born finishers | 
| 1975-97 | Top 25 men and women (1981-97), to include top 25 Division I Americans | 
| 1998-2004 | Top 30, to include the top 30 Americans | 
| 2005-07 | Top 30, to include the top 30 Americans (team must have USTFCCCA membership) | 
| 2008-Present | Top 40 without regard to citizenship (team must have USTFCCCA membership) | 
| Indoor Track & Field | |
| Year(s) | Requirements | 
| 1965-73 | Top three per event | 
| 1974-81 | Unknown | 
| 1982-87 | Top six per event | 
| 1989-2005 | Top eight per event, to include the top eight U.S.-born finishers | 
| 2006-10 | Top eight per event, to include the top eight U.S.-born finishers (team must have USTFCCCA membership) | 
| 2011-Present | Top eight First Team; 9-16 Second Team (team must have USTFCCCA membership) | 
| Outdoor Track & Field | |
| Year(s) | Requirements | 
| 1942-62 | Top three per event | 
| 1963-74 | Top four per event | 
| 1975-81 | Unknown | 
| 1982-84 | Top 12 per event | 
| 1985-2005 | Top eight per event, to include the top eight U.S.-born finishers | 
| 2006-10 | Top eight per event, to include the top eight U.S.-born finishers (team must have USTFCCCA membership) | 
| 2011-Present | Top eight First Team; 9-16 Second Team (team must have USTFCCCA membership) | 

 |
 |